|
1993 - 1996 Research
September 2001 Research
THE EFFICACY OF THE THERMOTEX INFRARED
HEATING BLANKET ON THE STANDARDBRED RACEHORSE. Study
conducted by Dr. Ronald J. Riegel D.V.M.
Hypothesis
Harness racing is one of the most demanding of all of the
equine athletic endeavors. Months of foundation miles are
accomplished before this athlete is even close to race
condition and speed. After this long period of training, the
animal must then drop in time, over the mile distance, to be
competitive. This hard training regime is extremely taxing
upon the equine athlete and all methods must be considered
to alleviate the pain and inflammation within the
musculature to ensure the success of this equine athlete.
The Thermotex™
Infrared heating blanket has been scientifically proven to
be effective in providing deep heat to the musculature of
the equine athlete. Infrared thermographs correlated with
blood chemistry analysis will provide proof that this
physical therapy modality is effective in relieving both
pain and inflammation within the muscle tissues of these
equine athletes.
Infrared Heat as a Physical
Therapy Modality
An infrared
thermograph is a pictorial photograph of the surface
temperature of the anatomical area it is measuring. The
circulatory system, inflammation, environmental changes, the
metabolic rate of the animal and other individual
thermographic characteristics influences its measurements.
The use of infrared thermography as a measurement of the
efficacy of different therapeutic modalities is easily
accomplished. Changes within thermal gradients can depict a
decrease or increase in circulation, a decrease or increase
in inflammation and even nerve irritation somewhere along
the neuron pathway. Therapeutic results can be visualized by
a series of infrared thermographs taken over a period of
time and then compared.
Goals
These are the questions that will be answered by this
research endeavor.
1. Will the infrared thermal gradients within the
musculature of the lumbar and sacral spinal anatomical areas
be reduced when treatment with the Thermotex™ infrared
heating equipment is applied?
2. What are the clinical pathological changes within the
blood chemistry levels as an animal receives treatment with
the Thermotex™ Therapy blanket?
3. Will there be a correlation between the thermographic
findings and the blood serum chemistry findings?
Infrared Thermography
Racing equine have track records that are public
information. Typically, as with their human athlete
counterparts, the presence of injury causes a reduction in
their performance. When treated with Thermotex™ (controlling
for pathologies and no other clinical intervention) the
animals returned to their original track records. Unlike
their human counterparts, horses have limited cognitive
abilities. Therefore, it would be very difficult to argue
any precognition or anticipation of outcome of a clinical
intervention on the part of the horse.
Blood Chemistry Analysis
AST is an abbreviation for Aspartate aminotransferase which
is the synonym for the old term SGOT (serum glutamic
oxaloacetic transaminase). This enzyme occurs in almost all
cells within the body but it is used to primarily diagnose
liver and muscle disease. The liver and muscle cells have
the highest activity of this enzyme. In itself it is not
specific for a liver disorder but is more diagnostic for the
muscle tissues.
Aspartate aminotransferase is present in the mitochondria
and the cytoplasmic fluid within the cells. The serum levels
of this enzyme are increased following hard exercise or
skeletal muscle injury. Circulating concentrations of this
enzyme will peak approximately 24 hours after an inciting
incident and return to normal within 7-10 days.
CPK (CK) is an abbreviation for Creatine phosphokinase (or
Creatine kinase). This is the most organ specific of all of
the clinical enzymes. Most serum CPK activity is from a
muscular origin. The plasma half-life of this enzyme is
short and will peak as early as six hours. This enzyme will
then only take 2-3 days to return to normal.
Procedure and Methodology
Two groups of ten three and four-year-old standardbred
racehorses that are in full training were utilized as the
test subjects. These twenty animals will have to meet the
following criteria:
- These animals will be healthy upon physical
examination.
- The animals will be serviceably sound and not had
any or be giving any systematic or intraarticular
medications. This includes all steroidal and
nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory medications such as
phenylbutazone, flunixin meglumine and corticosteroids.
- Training schedules and racing times are all similar
and nearly in the same class of races.
- All other physical therapy modalities and topical
applications of counter-irritants discontinued at least
seven days before the initiation of this project.
The study will last six weeks, have a two-week break to all
equine subjects and then resume with the control group
becoming the treatment group and the treatment group
becoming the control group for another six weeks.
All twenty animals will be thermographed initially, and then
at weekly intervals during the duration of the study. Blood
samples will be taken initially from all of the animals and
then repeated weekly until the conclusion of the study.
These blood samples will be evaluated for a complete blood
count and total serum chemistry analysis.
The complete blood count will have the following parameters
tested:
- RBC count
- WBC count
- Packed cell volume
- The types of WBCs
- In addition to all the normal tests
Serum chemistry analysis included:
-
Albumin levels - 35 - 50% of the serum protein
-
Alkaline Phosphatase levels - hepatic function
-
BUN - renal function
-
Calcium - calcium metabolism
-
Creatinine - renal function
-
Glucose - measured to monitor other diseases
-
Magnesium - magnesium metabolism
-
Phosphorus - phosphorus metabolism
-
AST(SGOT)
-
Serum protein -nutritive function
-
Total bilirubin - hepatic function
-
Sodium - electrolyte balance
-
Potassium - electrolyte balance
-
Chloride - electrolyte balance
-
GGT - renal function
-
CPK(CK)
-
A/G ratio - albumin/globulin ratio: total protein values
-
Globulin - calculated by subtracting the albumin conc.
from the total
protein concentration
-
Lipemic index - hepatic function
-
Hemolytic index - a value that may affect other tests
-
Icteric Index - hepatic function
The animals will randomly placed into two groups: a
treatment group and a control group.
Those animals within the control group will not receive any
treatments with the Thermotex™ therapy blanket during that
portion of the study. The animals within the treatment group
will receive treatment for thirty minutes each day just
before exercise. The temperature control was placed on the
high setting for ten minutes and then on low for the
remaining twenty minute duration of the treatment.
Infrared thermographs and blood samples were taken every
seven days for a total of fourteen weeks.
Results and Discussion
Thermographic Results:
The initial infrared thermograph (see initial thermograph - animal #5) revealed an increased
thermal gradient over the thoracic, lumbar and lumbosacral
spine. This thermograph was taken at a setting of 0.5
degrees centigrade per isothermic level. White is the
highest reading and purple is the coldest or lowest level
with a five-degree difference between them. These areas
depicted by the color white were fairly symmetrical except
within the lumbosacral area. In this anatomical area, there
is an increased thermal gradient predominantly on the left
side. These areas of white, gold and yellow reveal an
increased thermal gradient within the tissues that is
indicative of an inflammatory response within.
This particular animal (#5) was chosen as an example of the
entire study since the response within this animal was close
to the average of animals within the entire study. This
animal also palpated digitally with a slight tenderness
throughout the areas that are depicted by the color white.
After eight weeks of training without any treatment, the
infrared thermograph of animal number five revealed the
following comparisons to the initial thermograph. (see
infrared thermograph - animal #5 - week 8) There is an
increase within all of the thermal gradients as compared to
the initial findings. The increased thermal gradients
throughout the thoracic spine now continue into the right
shoulder region. Those increased thermal gradients within
the lumbar and lumbosacral areas have increased in intensity
and are now more predominant on the left side continuing
into the gluteal areas. These increases are due to a
rigorous training schedule and are normal for an animal that
is receiving no therapeutic help for this inflammation.
All ten of the animals that were in the control group
depicted these types of thermographs for the first eight
weeks of the study. They were all becoming increasingly sore
and their thermographs all revealed increases along the
lumbar and sacral spine.
Immediately after treatment with the Thermotex™ therapy
blanket, there was a huge increase within the thermal
gradients within the tissues. This increase lasted an
average of four to five hours after the treatment was
concluded. These thermographs were done before the
initiation of the study just to establish a baseline of
data. During the study, the animals were always exercised
after their treatment, which also increased the thermal
gradients found within the individual making the duration of
effect impossible to measure.
The infrared thermograph taken of animal #5 at the
conclusion of the study revealed large decreases within the
thermal gradients along all of the anatomical areas
examined. (see
infrared thermograph - animal #5 - week 14) Within the lumbosacral
spine area there is a remarkable 95% reduction within the
thermal gradients. Clinically, this also corresponds to
insensitivity upon digital palpation. The thoracic and
thoracolumbar spinal areas also experienced a reduction
within the thermal gradients to an extent of a 68%
reduction. This area was also no longer sensitive to digital
palpation.
Serum Chemistry Results:
The AST levels for the ten animals that served in the
control group were consistently high during the first eight
weeks of the study and then gradually dropped to lower
levels during the last six weeks of the study.
(see
table one data, graph and chart of averages)
Initially, seven of the ten animals tested with higher than
normal AST levels within the serum. By week eight, eight of
the ten animals depicted AST levels higher than normal.
After the initiation of treatment at week eight, these
levels gradually fell, in all but those animals testing
normally, to a level lower than that found at the eight week
tests. By week fourteen, six of the ten animals were now
testing within normal limits. The results seen within chart
one summarize this data.
Those animals that initially received treatment for six
weeks and then were left untreated revealed quite different
results within their AST levels.
(see
table two data, graph and chart of averages)
Five of these ten animals depicted higher than normal AST
levels at the initiation of treatment. Nine of the ten
animals experienced an immediate drop within the first week
of treatment. By week six, seven of the ten animals were
testing within normal AST ranges. After the cessation of
treatments, seven of the ten animals within this group
immediately experienced a rise within the AST levels during
week seven. At fourteen weeks, eight of the ten animals
revealed higher AST levels than those measured initially.
The data graphed on chart two reveals this decline in AST
levels through week six and then a gradual increase when the
use of Thermotex™ blanket was stopped.
The CK levels followed the same pattern as the AST levels
within the group of ten animals that was used as a control
for eight weeks and then provided treatment.
(see
table three data, graph and chart of averages)
Initially, five of the ten animals tested within the normal
limits for CK levels in the horse. By week eight, six of the
animals tested with an increase in CK levels over those
initial levels. Over the next six weeks, during treatment
with the Thermotex™ therapy blanket, all ten of the animals
experienced a decline in CK levels. Eight of the ten animals
are now testing within normal limits. The other two animals
could even be considered in the high normal range.
Chart three is a summary of all of the averages on a weekly
basis. During the control part of the study, the group
maintained an even level throughout the first 6-8 weeks.
After the initiation of treatment, the CK levels gradually
fell.
When the animals initially received treatment and then
became the control group, the results mimicked those of the
same AST group.
(see
table four data, graph and chart of averages)
Initially, only four of the ten animals tested within normal
limits for CK. After six weeks of treatment with the
Thermotex™ therapy blanket, six of the ten animals were
within normal limits. By the time fourteen weeks had passed,
Seven of the ten animals exhibited higher than normal levels
with seven of the ten animals also showing increased levels
from the initial testing. Chart four exhibits the gradual
decline in CK levels and then the gradual increase after
treatment protocols have ceased.
The summary of the blood chemistry analysis revealed that
the AST and CK levels were lower during treatment with the
Thermotex™ therapy blanket.
(see
table five data and graph)
As depicted on the data table and corresponding graph, the
AST and CK levels increased while the animals were in
training and not receiving treatment with the Thermotex™
therapy blanket and decreased when receiving treatment.
Summary and Conclusions
-
There is thermographic and serum chemistry evidence that
the therapy provided by the Thermotex™ therapy blanket
is efficacious.
-
The lowering of both the AST and CK levels indicates
that treatment with the Thermotex™ therapy blanket
alleviates the inflammatory response within the muscles
of the standardbred racehorses that are in training.
-
Thermographic evidence provides evidence of a decrease
within the inflammatory response and some analgesia when
the Thermotex™ therapy blanket is used on a daily basis
on the standardbred racehorse.
-
This evidence concludes that the Thermotex™ therapy
blanket is an ideal drug free modality to use before
competition, as a therapy program in itself, as an
adjunct to.
References
- Baxter, Michael. The Art and Science of Specialized
Kinesiology. Academy of Equine Sport Therapy. 1994.
- Bromiley, Mary. Physiotherapy in Veterinary
Practice. Blackwell Scientific Publications Editorial
Offices. 1991. Pg. 16-21.
- Riegel, Ronald and Hakola, S. Illustrated Atlas of
Clinical Equine Anatomy and Common Disorders of the
Horse. Equistar Publications Ltd. 1996
- Stashak, S. Ted. Adam's Lameness in Horses. Fourth
Edition. Lea and Febiger. 1987. Philadelphia. 1962.
|